Recaps & Roundups part 24: The Strategic Review #7

Cover-dated April 1976, this is the final issue of The Strategic Review. TSR has formed a new division, TSR Periodicals, which will oversee the creation of two new magazines: Little Wars for miniature wargaming, and The Dragon for fantasy gaming. One of those magazines doesn't last very long, and the other stays in print for over three decades before moving into the digital realm. No prizes for guessing which...

In other news, Mike Carr and Dave Sutherland are joining TSR, a game called Little Big Horn is in the works, and another game based on Lankhmar is being created. There's also an ad for Supplement III: Eldritch Wizardry, which says it will be on sale May 1st.

Other articles include a collection of military symbols for Classic Warfare, an exploration of ancient missile weapons (also for Classic Warfare), a fantasy short story (which I'm ignoring because it's not by a TSR designer),

The Dungeons & Dragons Magic System by Gary Gygax: Gary defends and clarifies D&D's "Vancian" spell system. Along the way he introduces the concept of spell components: verbal, somatic, material, and "psychic" (the last relating to the memorisation aspect of spells). He also breaks down the various spell effects by type, which is a step along the path to introducing the different schools of magic (conjuration, evocation, illusion, etc.). There's not much else here of interest to my project.

The Fastest Guns That Never Lived by Brian Blume: Boot Hill stats are given for various fictional cowboys: the Lone Ranger, Tonto, the Rifleman, Clint Eastwood, Yancy Derringer, Pahoo, Johnny Yuma, Matt Dillon, John Wayne, Paladin, Josh Randall, Yul Brynner, and Hopalong Cassidy. I only recognise about half of those, and obviously some of them are actors. Nevertheless, they'll all be around should players in my campaign venture to the Old West.

Hints for D&D Judges Part I: Towns by Joe Fischer: Some basic but solid advice for creating a home base for your PCs. The only possible relevance it has for me is the mention of Castle Black Star, the first level of which was given over to inns, pubs and shops, including the shop of a crazy wizard who employed a balrog named Boris and always seemed to have a little bit of everything (Gondorian Red, Mordorian Black, etc.). I started thinking about Black Star a while back based on some of Fischer's other articles, and may or may not develop it further.

Mighty Magic Miscellany by Neal Healey: A number of new magic items are introduced:

• The Cup and Talisman of Akbar
• Staff of the Priest Kings
• Brazen Bottle

The Cup and Talisman are carved with the name of Allah in Kufic script, which suggests that it might have originated on Earth (although paladins, rangers and dervishes can use it, which bears thinking about). The staff alludes to the existence of Priest Kings at some point in the past.

Creature Features: Two new monsters are introduced:

• Denebian Slime Devil
• Catoblepas

The catoblepas goes on to become an official monster, so it's definitely in my campaign. As for the Slime Devil, it's an obvious joke monster. I'll throw one in somewhere, in a place that's very difficult to find.

Thief Bonuses for Dexterity by David Klempa: The thief gets some bonuses to their skills for having a high Dexterity. The concept of "exceptional Dexterity" (akin to exceptional Strength for fighters) is brought in.

To the Everlasting Glory of the Petal Throne by MAR Barker: This is a collection of snippets of news and rumours as to what's going on in Tekumel, the setting for Empire of the Petal Throne. I won't go into any detail, because most of this will probably never be relevant to my project. I do plan to include a way for PCs to get to Tekumel, and I'm currently reading Empire of the Petal Throne to get a better grasp on the setting. I'll do an interlude post about it in the near future.

D&D is Only as Good as the DM by Gary Gygax: A DMing advice article mostly geared at keeping power levels down and fleecing PCs of their gold. Gary sticks the boots in to CalTech's ultra-high-level "Dungeons & Beavers" campaign, and notes that no PC in either Blackmoor or Greyhawk has advanced beyond 14th level.

Recaps & Roundups part 23: The Strategic Review #6

The February 1976 issue of The Strategic Review sees it expand into a number of different topics aside from D&D. It features articles on Fight in the Skies, War of Wizards, the Dungeon! board game, and Ancient Conquest. There's also an optional rule about how bravery affects shooting in Boot Hill, which may or may not be relevant in my campaign, depending on how deep it goes into Old West territory. In TSR news, the Dungeon hobby shop is just about ready to open, and Gary's Classic Warfare (which he had apparently worked on for over seven years) is now available. A line of D&D miniatures from Mini-Figs is on the horizon, and we see the first inklings of the mass combat supplement Swords & Spells.

The Meaning of Law and Chaos in Dungeons & Dragons by Gary Gygax: Gary goes into a deeper explanation of alignment and how it works in the D&D setting, adding Good and Evil to the system along with Law, Neitrality and Chaos. He begins with this chart:

From this chart we get the first proper mentions of:

• Hades, the plane of Evil
• Limbo, the plane of Chaos
• Nirvana, the plane of Law
• Paradise, the plane of Good
• Hell, the plane of Law and Evil, inhabited by Devils
• The Abyss, the plane of Chaos and Evil, inhabited by Demons
• Elysium, the plane of Chaos and Good, inhabited by Godlings
• Heaven, the plane of Law and Good, inhabited by Saints

Instead of three alignments, there are now five:

• Lawful Good (apparently typified by paladins)
• Chaotic Good (typified by elves)
• Neutral (typified by elementals)
• Lawful Evil (typified by vampires)
• Chaotic Evil (typified by demons)

Another chart is given that reclassified some monsters in the new system:

The reference to multiple Platinum and Chromatic Dragons might best be ignored, or applied in a multiversal sense (i.e. there's only one of each in every world, but multiples across reality).

It's mentioned that any character that follows any alignment (save neutrality) to the absolute letter must eventually move into the appropriate plane of existence - perhaps this could be one way of achieving demi-godhood.

This is interesting: "Also, law and chaos are not subject to interpretation in their ultimate meanings of order and disorder respectively, but good and evil are not absolutes but must be judged from a frame of reference, some ethos. The placement of creatures on the chart of Illustration II reflects the ethos of this writer to some extent".

The "universal constant" is said to be between law and chaos, and that in any final struggle both sides would be represented by creatures both good and evil. Barring that conflict, good creatures are more likely to band together, as are evil ones.

Paladins are now able to quest to regain their status should they lose their paladinhood due to evil/chaotic acts. High level clerics can also do so, but failure merely drops them back to 7th level.

Most humans are lawful, and somewhere in the middle between good and evil. The majority can be led to lawful good with the right leadership. Few are chaotic, and very few are chaotic evil.

The introduction of a new alignment axis should be a fairly world-shaking event, as it strikes at the fundamental nature of the D&D world. In the past I've considered using the introduction of various individual deities at this time as the catalyst, and that's still probably how I'll go. There are also discrepancies between the planes as charted in this article, and the planes as they'll eventually be revealed. I might chalk that up to faulty research by scholars.

The Quest for the Vermillion Volume by Rob Kuntz: This is a short story, which I'd normally ignore but am going to try to work into the campaign because it's written by Greyhawk co-DM Rob Kuntz. It tells the story of a group of adventurers who are hired by an elven queen to retrieve a book from agents of the enemy land of Stra-Tac. The adventurers manage to retrieve the book from enemy agents, but they fall into a trap set by a mysterious thief named "RST" who absconds with the book.

Here are some elements from the story for me to add to the campaign:

• The Greenwood, home to a number of elves (possibly the Elf-Land referred to in D&D Vol. 1: Men & Magic).
• Queen Evvolon, elven ruler of the Greenwood.
• The nearby land of Stra-Tac, which is an enemy of the Greenwood. The only people we know of that live there are human spies and hairy, brutish humanoids. These might be Orcs, but given the hair they could also be Bugbears.
• Dunn-Red, the ruler of Stra-Tac.
• Drystaff the Necromancer, leader of the adventurers searching for the book. He has a beard, a staff, and a pointy hat. A number of men-at-arms are in his employ, and he's working with elven scouts. Due to some anachronistic Earth references, he might have travelled there somehow, or simply scried it with his crystal ball.
• Grimm the Thaumaturgist, who was Drystaff's teacher.
• Drystaff's wife, who apparently cheats on him.
• Grumbold, Drystaff's mule.
• The Hog, a barbarian that Drystaff met in the past in the far north-east.
• Highton, the elven leader of the scouts, assigned to the mission by Evvolon.
• Lamhand, a Hero who works with Drystaff, possibly as his henchman.
• RST, the mysterious thief about whom very little is revealed.
• The titular Vermillion Volume. Not much is revealed about it, but it's sought after by Queen Evvolon and Dunn-Red the Enemy.
• The elves in this story are depicted less like Tolkien elves, and more like Christmas elves, with smaller stature and pointy shoes.

The lands mentioned in this story will have to small and of little importance in the larger scheem of the World of Greyhawk, because I'm pretty sure they don't appear on the official maps. I'll have the story as having happened recently, so that the PCs might get embroiled in the search for the book.

Bards by Doug Schwegmen: The Bard class is introduced for the first time, in a form much closer to the 3rd edition incarnation than the weird AD&D version.

• Bards and Druids belong to the same sect, and must aid each other when in need.
• There are a number of bardic "colleges", in order from lowest to highest: Fochlucan, Mac-Fuirmidh, Doss, Canaith, Cli, Anstruth, Ollamh.
• An adventure hook is given: a dragon who refuses to let a bard stop playing his restful melodies.

Mighty Magic Miscellany: A number of Bard-related magic instruments are introduced:

• Fochlucan Harp
• Mac-Fuirmidh Harp
• Doss Lyre
• Canaith Lyre
• Cli Mandolin

Sage Advice by "Theronius": Errata is given for Supplement I, giving details for the Homunculus, Golems, the rod of resurrection, the gem of seeing and the gauntlets of dexterity.

Recaps & Roundups part 22: The Character Archaic

Cover art by Morno

The Character Archaic, published in September 1975, was the first commercially available set of character sheets for D&D. They were published by Wee Warriors, a company founded by husband and wife team Pete and Judy Kerestan. While not technically a TSR product, it was distributed by TSR, as were several later Wee Warriors products, so I'll be covering them when I reach them in the timeline.

Although TSR had yet to release any character sheets of their own, by this point they apparently had developed some for internal use. According to the Acaeum they were on top-tearing pads, and printed on green, orange, or white paper. Here's one of the sheets below:

I don't have access to a copy of The Character Archaic, so I'm relying on second-hand knowledge and some photos to tell me what's inside the thing. The Acaeum says that it features 20 character sheets, a dungeon map, a creature encounter sheet, a character roll call, and a combat matrix reference.  I'm not sure what those last three entail, but I do have some examples of the character sheets and a photo of the dungeon map.

Both of the above sheets are identical except for the illustration in the top corner of the right page. I'm not sure, but it's possible that there are more illustrations than the two shown above. It's interesting to note that these sheets aren't strictly for D&D; among the ability scores are Psychic Ability and Comeliness, which suggests that the sheets are also intended for use with Empire of the Petal Throne. To be honest, they seem to be more geared towards EPT than D&D, with spaces for skills and training, as well as bonuses to hit and damage for every ability score.

The dungeon map is labelled 'The Wizard's Tomb', and I have a photo below (taken from a thread on RPGGeek).

That's not the whole thing, obviously, as some of it is frustratingly cut off at the bottom. Rooms 1 through 13 can be seen clearly, as well as Room 24. There are also three numbered areas in the long passage to the left, so it's likely that there are seven others room that we can't see. Does anyone know if there are any better images of this map out there?

There were definitely other character sheets out there in 1975, and you can check out a list of them over at Playing at the World.  Most of those were in 'zines and newsletters. TSR wouldn't publish their own until 1977, so for about two years The Character Archaic was as official as it got.

Interlude 2: Warriors of Mars - The Warfare of Barsoom in Miniature

Midway through 1974 (I'm not sure exactly when but the Forward is dated to July)  TSR published Warriors of Mars, a set of miniature wargame rules based on Edgar Rice Burroughs' John Carter novels. There was only ever one print run, though, because the Burroughs estate was very quick to let TSR know that they were infringing on their IP rights. Consequently this book is very rare, but because the internet is awesome it can be found at archive.org, which is how I've been able to read a copy.

The game was written by Gary Gygax and Brian Blume, and not surprisingly it bears some resemblance to Chainmail. It covers large-scale combat with figures representing 50 men, and smaller conflicts where a figure represents one man. There are also rules for aerial warfare, and notes on many of the various characters and weird alien creatures from the books.

As for why I'm covering it, there are a bunch of references to Barsoom, the setting of these books, in the first D&D boxed set.  Most notably these come in the Wilderness Wandering Monster tables, where a decent variety of Barsoomian creatures are given as optional encounter possibilities. None of them were given stats in D&D, so I thought I'd scour Warriors of Mars to see if I can get some guidance on the matter.

Before I start, these are the creatures I'll want stats for:

Red, Black, Yellow and White Martians (all basically human-like)
Tharks (Green Martians)
Apts
Banths
Thoats
Calots
White Apes
Orluks
Sith
Darseen

The first bit of good news is that Warriors of Mars has movement rates that are given in inches, and seem to be comparable to those used in Chainmail/D&D.  I've reproduced the table below:

That covers movement rates for all of the creatures on the D&D tables. With humans moving at 12" the scale seems to be identical, so I can use these numbers as is.

Things get a bit harder when working out combat stats, though, because the combat in Warriors of Mars doesn't use the same system as Chainmail or D&D. It's much more chart-based, which makes it difficult to draw comparisons. The chart below, showing the combat ability of various characters and troop types, is helpful though.

The people of Barsoom are definitely hardier and more warlike than those of Earth, so using the scale above I think it's fair to equate the above numbers to D&D levels/Hit Dice. They serve a similar function in Warriors of Mars, being both combat ability as well as the number of hits a figure can take before being killed. John Carter would thus be a 13th level fighter, pretty much at the top of the scale for OD&D, but that's a fair assessment for someone described as the finest swordsman of two worlds. Red, Black, Yellow and White Martians would all have Hit Dice based on their individual skill level and the chart above. I guess most of their warriors would be in the 3-5 HD range, with leaders and elite guards ranging from 6 HD up to 10 HD. 11 HD and over seems to be reserved for the super-badass characters from the books.

That brings me to the table used for when someone is fighting a Barsoomian monster.

Most of those numbers are irrelevant for my purposes, but on the far left of the chart there's a column for "Wounds to Kill". This is pretty much the same rating as the one used for men above, so I'm happy to use it to calculate Hit Dice for the various Martian animals in D&D.

And so, here are the stats I gleaned for each one (not including the men, who are going to vary greatly):

Tharks
Green martians with four arms that live in tribes.
Movement: 12"
Hit Dice: 6

Apts
Tusked, six-limbed beasts of the frozen north pole region.
Movement: 12"
Hit Dice: 6

Banths
Lion-like beasts with ten legs.
Movement: 15"
Hit Dice: 7

Thoats
Horse-like creatures with eight legs.
Movement: 21"
Hit Dice: 5

Calots
Dog-like creatures with ten legs
Movement: 24"
Hit Dice: 5

White Apes
Semi-intelligent four-armed apes that inhabit the wilds and ruined cities.
Movement: 12"
Hit Dice: 6

Orluks
Described in this game as being similar to a jaguar, but in the Barsoom wiki as "elephantine".
Movement: 12"
Hit Dice: 4

Sith
Large predatory insects
Movement: 9"/30" flying
Hit Dice: 10

Darseen
A whole range of Barsoomian lizards, with these stats referring to the giant variety.
Movement: 9"
Hit Dice: 4

It's only two stats, with no Armor Class or damage or anything else, but for OD&D purposes Movement and Hit Dice are enough to go on. Everything in OD&D does 1d6 damage, and AC can be worked out by comparing to similar D&D monsters. This will all be handy for future reference, should PCs in my campaign ever end up on the red planet.

Interlude 1: Tunnels & Trolls

Seeing as it's credited as the second fantasy role-playing game in existence, I thought it might be fun to take a break in my timeline at the end of 1975 for a look at Tunnels & Trolls. It was created by Ken St. Andre who, upon looking at a friend's copy of Dungeons & Dragons, promptly decided that the game was confusing and wrote his own rules based around the same concept. Tunnels & Trolls was published in April 1975, and for a time was D&D's biggest competitor.

For this post I took a look at the game's first edition, and had a couple of attempts at a solo adventure using the Buffalo Castle module.

The first thing I was struck by upon reading the rules is the scope of Tunnels & Trolls: it's completely focused on dungeon adventuring, lacking D&D's digressions into wilderness adventures, aerial combat, naval battles, etc. It's only a third of the size, so I guess it never was going to be as expansive.

Character creation is similar, with six stats all rolled in 3d6. These stats are the same as those used in D&D, except for Wisdom which has been replaced by Luck. Instead of Fighters, Magic-Users and Clerics, the classes in T&T are Warriors, Wizards and Rogues. It's possible that St. Andre saw the Greyhawk supplement before writing his game (or perhaps the earlier version of the Thief class published in a 'zine), but it's also possible that he came up with the idea on his own. To be honest, though, the two classes aren't at all similar; the Rogue in T&T is more of a fighter/magic-user hybrid, with none of the thief's stealth and trap-finding skills.

Combat is even more abstracted than in D&D. Each side rolls a bunch of dice (always 6-siders) and adds a certain number to the total. For PCs, the dice rolled depends upon the weapon wielded, and the numbers added or subtracted are based on Strength, Luck and Dexterity. Monsters use a different system: each monster has a rating, which determines their hit points as well as the number of dice they roll.  A monster rolls dice, and on the first combat turn adds half their Monster Rating. On the second turn, they only add a quarter. The higher number wins, and the difference is subtracted from the loser's Constitution.  With larger groups, everyone on every side totals their dice and adds, and the side that loses has to spread the damage out among their number.

The magic system is point-based rather than using spell slots and memorisation like D&D, requiring the caster to expend Strength points for every spell.  The spell names are whimsical, and fit the humourous tone that T&T is going for, with names like "Take That You Fiend" and "Curse You". I've never played T&T or read a manual before today, but the one thing I knew about it was that it had weird spell names. Are T&T fans fond of them? I'd probably change them if I ever ran the game in an ongoing fashion. Maybe I just hate fun or something.

Disappointingly for me (because I love reading RPG monster entries), there are no monster stats in T&T. This isn't such a big deal, because all you need to come up with is a single number for the Monster Rating, and maybe some rules for its special abilities. The MR covers its hit points, how much damage it does, and how much XP its worth. It's a simple system (perhaps too simple), but it would be great for running games on the fly with no preparation.

With a basic grasp of the rules, I rolled up a character to take on an adventure into Buffalo Castle. Here he is below:

NAME: Ferdinand the Slinker
TYPE: Rogue

STR: 8; INT:  11; LUCK: 12; CON: 7; DEX: 8; CHA: 11

GOLD: 100

I bought Ferdinand some clothes, a pack, sandals, a sword, a dagger, and a steel cap. The sword would be my primary weapon, being worth 2 dice. The cap gave me a +1 bonus to Constitution.

In my first foray into the castle, I encountered a troll sitting on a chest. I tried to talk to him, which required me to add 3d6 plus my Charisma and Luck together. I got a total of 32, which wasn't quite high enough to stop the troll from attacking me.

Failing that I tried to run, which required a Saving Roll. Every character has a Saving Roll number, which is equal to 20 - Luck. (This number gets higher on lower dungeon levels.) Ferdinand had a Saving Roll of 8. I needed to get higher than that on two dice (although rolling doubles allows you to roll again and add to the total). I rolled a 6, so I wasn't able to escape, and the Troll hit me for 2 damage.

I had to fight the Troll, who had a Monster Rating of 40 and rolled 5 dice in combat. On the first round, it was his 5d6+20 vs. my paltry 2d6-2. I rolled for myself, scoring a 5. I didn't even bother rolling for the Troll, as I was dead no matter what. Mathematically there was no chance for me to win or even damage the Troll. He would have been down to 5d6+10 on the second round, but even then the battle was impossible. Maybe rolling doubles in combat lets you keep adding numbers as well? That would make things a little better.

And now, for my second character:

NAME: Mangfred the Manful
TYPE: Warrior

STR: 11; INT: 5; LUCK: 8; CON: 8; DEX: 9; CHA: 8

GOLD: 140

I bought Mangfred a mace (worth 3 dice), some leather armor (+2 Con) and a steel cap (+1 Con).

Immediately I fell into a pit (failing my Saving Roll of 12), losing 2 CON. I found a secret door in the bottom of the pit, which led to a treasure room with seemingly unlimited gold pieces. In reality, I could keep shoveling gold into his pack indefinitely, but for every 10gp I had to check for Wandering Monsters. I rolled badly on the first round, and was attacked by an Orc.

The Orc was much more manageable than the Troll, with a Monster Rating of 16 and 3 dice. I rolled by 3d6-1, scoring a meagre 6. He rolled his 3d6+8, and scored a 16. Again, I had been killed in the first round of combat.

I'm not sure if I just had bad luck with the dice, or if Tunnels & Trolls is absurdly deadly. Certainly, its combat system is far more reliant on equipment and ability scores than D&D's, which makes your class the primary factor in combat effectiveness (especially original D&D< which had every weapon dealing 1d6 damage). I definitely rolled poor stats for both of my guys: going with straight 3d6 down the line results in some crushingly mediocre characters, and in this game it's punishing.

Reading the manual, I found Tunnels & Trolls charming. It has an impish, whimsical sense of humour, and strikes me as more fairy-tale in tone than D&D's pulp sword & sorcery roots. It's simple and fast-paced, and would be perfect for impromptu pick-up games. Actually trying to play it was another experience. I gather the system was greatly improved in later editions, but having tried to play it solo I'm not convinced that it works. Again, it could just have been my cruel dice, but everything just seemed far too stacked in the favour of the monsters. With the best weapon and perfect stats, I would have been rolling 4d6+18 against the Troll, which might just have scraped me through. But let's face it, those perfect stats aren't going to happen, so I have no idea how a 1st level character would beat it. Then again, a 1st level character isn't beating a Troll in D&D either, and it might just be that it's Buffalo Castle that's unbalanced rather than Tunnels & Trolls as a whole. Maybe I misunderstood the rules? After all, it's been in print for over 40 years, it must be doing something right.

As a final note, I was surprised to see the term Dungeon Master being thrown about quite freely in this game.  As far as I know, the term doesn't see print in a D&D product until Supplement II: Blackmoor, which T&T predates by a good six months. Did T&T create the term, or was it a phrase that was in wide circulation with gamers already?  Regardless, it's possible that this might be the first time that the game referee is called a Dungeon Master in print.

Recaps & Roundups part 21: The Strategic Review #5

Cover art by Greg Bell

This issue of The Strategic Review is cover-dated December 1975. The news section notes right away that Blackmoor was off to the printers, and that it should be available in stores by the time this issue came out. In other news, TSR is just about to open the Dungeon Hobby Shop in Lake Geneva, which I understand is sadly no longer in business. A bunch of other games are in development: Fight in the Skies, Little Big Horn, Lankhmar, Classic Warfare and a Robin Hood game. Mention is also made that Supplement IV: Gods, Demigods & Heroes will be out before the next Gen Con. Also: THE DRAGON IS COMING!

In non-D&D articles we have some bios of the TSR staff, an article about the Battle of the Nile by Dave Arneson, and some new weapons for Tractics.

Sturmgeshutz and Sorcery by Gary Gygax: In this article, Gary recounts a conflict between the inhabitants of a castle from the World of Greyhawk and a Nazi SS Patrol. A strange fog sprang up west of the castle, which allowed passage both ways, from Oerth to 1940s Germany and back.

The master of the castle is "The Gatherer", a 12th level evil high priest. His lieutenants Grustiven the Warlock and Goocz the Lama had previously disappeared through the fog. Many of the Gatherer's strongest fighters and 200 orcs are off warring with a neutral Lord who insulted him earlier. I'll no doubt place the Gatherer's forces, as well as those of this mysterious Lord, somewhere in castles in the vicinity of Greyhawk city.

During the battle between D&D baddies and SS troops, the Gatherer lost some ghouls, a troll, a giant scorpion, and a number of orcs. The Nazis were driven back to their camp. These events will absolutely be a part of my campaign's history.

Below are the game maps of the area.

I'll assume that the German map is correct for their side of the fog, and the Servants' map is accurate for the Oerth side. I might have to ignore the arrow pointing north, as the text says that the fog appeared to the west of the castle. Maybe it's north for the Germans and west for the Servants.

Mighty Magic Miscellany: This gives two new magic items:

• Robe of Scintillating Colours
• Prayer Beads

The types of Prayer Beads introduced are:

• Bead of Atonement
• Bead of Response
• Bead of Damnation
• Bead of Karma
• Bead of Succor
• Bead of Hindrance

In the Prayer Bead entry it introduces the idea the deities might respond to prayers and give aid, while also noting that they are fickle and dangerous.

Gallery of Gunfighters: A bio and stats for Ben Thompson.

Creature Features: Three new monsters are introduced:

• Rakshasa
• Slithering Tracker
• Trapper

Rakshasa are said to be "known first in India", which either indicates that they originated on Earth, or that they're from a place that either culturally or geographically corresponds with India on Oerth. I favour the latter, but it should be noted that travel back and forth from Earth to Oerth is establised elsewhere in this issue.

Recaps & Roundups part 20: Supplement II - Blackmoor

The first D&D supplement was Greyhawk, featuring many game elements that had developed through play in Gary Gygax's home campaign. Naturally, the second supplement came from D&D's other progenitor, Dave Arneson, and was called Blackmoor. The development of this supplement was fraught: apparently Arneson was working on the final draft in March of 1975, but it had to go through two different editors, and was temporarily misplaced. The final edit was done hastily in a few weeks, and Blackmoor was finally published around December of 1975.

The finished product is patchy, and contains almost no detail on Arneson's Blackmoor campaign, but it does introduce a number of lasting elements to the game. I'll quickly run through them below.

New Rules Introduced

• Hit Location during Melee
• Lycanthropy gets more detail
• Underwater adventuring
• Specialised knowledge and expanded rules for Sages
• Disease

New Classes Introduced

• Monks (a sub-class of clerics)
• Assassins (a sub-class of thieves)

Monsters in the game already that get updated or given stats

• Merman
• Giant Crab
• Giant Octopus
• Giant Squid
• Giant Crocodile
• Giant Toad
• Giant Leech

New Monsters Introduced

• Giant Frog
• Giant Beaver
• Giant Otter
• Giant Wasp
• Giant Stag Beetle
• Rhinoceros Beetle
• Bombardier Beetle
• Fire Beetle
• Boring Beetle
• Fire Lizard
• Minotaur Lizard
• Elasmosaurus
• Mosasaurus
• Plesiosaurus
• Giant Shark
• Whale
• Giant Eel
• Lamprey
• Sea Horse
• Portuguese Man-of-War
• Dolphin
• Aquatic Elf (aka Sea Elf)
• Pungi Ray
• Manta Ray
• Giant Sea Spider
• Weed Eel
• Sahuagin (Devil-Men of the Deep)
• Floating Eyes
• Ixitxachitl
• Locathah
• Morkoth (aka Morlock)
• Poisonous Coral
• Masher
• Strangle Weed
• Nymph (as a Dryad variant)
• Mottled Worm (as a Purple Worm variant)
• Sea Hag (as a sort of reverse Dryad)
• Kopoacinth (aquatic gargoyles)
• Koalinth (aquatic hobgoblins)
• Lacedons (aquatic ghouls)

New Magic Items

• Ring of Freedom
• Ring of Movement
• Clearwater Potion
• Manta Ray Cloak
• Necklace of Water Breathing
• Trident of Fish Control
• Net of Snaring
• Black Pearls
• Gold Pearls
• Red Pearls
• Helm of Underwater Vision

New Types of Treasure

• Pearls
• Pink Pearls
• Silver Pearls

Diseases Introduced

• Grippe
• Bubonic Plague
• Dysentery
• Cholera
• Malaria
• Small Pox
• Tuberculosis
• Typhus
• Typhoid Fever
• Yellow Fever
• Crud (heat rash, athlete's foot, jungle rot, ringworm)
• Advanced Leprosy (

New Adventure Location - The Temple of the Frog

• Deep within the misty swamps of Lake Gloomey lies the city of the Brothers of the Swamp, who believe that man is a biological abomination that threatens the existence of all life, and that animals should rule.
• The Brothers of the Swamp began developing a creature that combined amphibians with the killer instincts of larger mammals, creating the giant killer frog. For years they hewed out caverns below their temple as breeding areas, offering human victims as sacrifice to a giant idol they called the Lord of the Swamp.
• A special order, the Keepers of the Frogs, were created to tend the beasts, but eventually grew disdainful of them.
• The temple tried to sustain itself by trading goods and purchasing slaves, disguised as merchants from "far places".
• About 100 years ago, the Brothers gave sanctuary to some bandits in return for obtaining some needed articles. These bandits now reside in the temple, dominating non-religious life within in an unholy fashion. The temple became less a holy order than an outlaw kingdom, and this state of affairs lasted about a generation.
• Stephen the Rock and three followers later appeared and quickly took over. Two of those followers died. Now the temple trades good of high quality, and Stephen has restored much of its original purpose. The location of the temple remains secret, but the place is organised, and the swamps around it teem with killer frogs.
• Stephen comes from another world or dimension. His people discovered a dimensional nexus point in the area of Blackmoor, and he and his followers were sent to police it against incursions from similar beings. His people must have been technologically advanced, as Stephen must report yearly to a hovering satellite station, and possesses a number of powerful devices.

Details and conjecture relevant to the Ultimate Sandbox

• Dread "Blackmoor Castle" is mentioned.
• Monks belong to the Order of Monastic Martial Arts. Under "followers" it's mentioned that monks can't have followers from a different Order, so this is not necessarily one monolithic organisation. After 6th level, there is only one monk of each level thereafter. In order, these levels are: Grand Master of Dragons, Grand Master of the North Wind, Grand Master of the West Wind, Grand Master of the South Wind, Grand Master of the East Wind, Grand Master of Winter, Grand Master of Autumn, Grand Master of Summer, Grand Master of Spring, and Grand Master of Flowers. Monks can only advance above 6th level by challenging and defeating the master directly above them in a fair fight.
• All of the seasons are mentioned, confirming that Oerth has similar seasons to Earth.
• All assassins belong to an Assassin's Guild. There can only be one Guildmaster (13th level), who can be challenged for leadership by another assassin of 12th level.
• There is only one Assassin's Guild in a large city or area of 2,500 square miles.
• For some reason, people react with ferocity to poisoned weapons. Hatred of these may have been drilled into the populace by the Church of Law, perhaps.
• Mermen ride around on the back of seahorses
• Fire Lizards are believed to be the ancestors of dragons, and dragons will avoid fighting them.
• The "Portuguese" Man-of-War should hail from whatever region of Oerth corresponds most closely to Portugal, whether culturally or geographically.
• Dolphins are very intelligent, hate sharks, can communicate with each other telepathically, have magic resistance like dwarves, and can detect magic. Apparently.
• In eons past the land was flooded (this might have happened more than once) when the ice caps melted during a great struggle of the gods to control the planet. Some gods protected their mortal charges, while others changed the nature of life to adapt to the ocean. Sea elves and mermen was thus created by the gods of Neutrality and Law, while the gods of Chaos created the Sahuagin.
• The underwater sahuagin capital city has a population of nearly 100,000.
• There is one Sahuagin King and nine Princes, all subject to challenge for their position by other Sahuagin.
• Sahuagin never stop growing throughout their lives.
• Ixitxachitl are "Chaotic Clerical Philosophers".
• Lycanthropy can affect animals, turning them into men with animal intelligence.
• Some gnomes live underwater in air-enclosed cities connected to the surface by tunnels.
• Some kobolds live underwater in air-enclosed caves connected to the surface by tunnels.
• There are Evil High Priests who live in underwater castles surrounded by a spell that allows those within to breath.
• Giant Leeches, Ochre Jellies, Green Slime, Ropers, and Gelatinous Cubes can all seemingly survive under the sea.
• Mu, Lemuria and Atlantis are mentioned.
• It's possible that Sages are favoured by the Gods of Law, because killing one will change your alignment instantly to Chaotic (unless the Sage was Chaotic).
• Mummy rot is also named advanced leprosy, perhaps by scholars trying to understand it scientifically (they will probably be wrong, because I don't think this sticks).
• Spotted Fever is the name given to the disease carried by Giant Ticks.
• There's a rare type of bark that can cure malaria. It's also relished by Displacer Beasts and Blink Dogs, which I'm considering as the root of their mutual enmity.

Recaps & Roundups part 19: Dungeons & Dragons boxed set, 4th printing

By late 1975, the Dungeons & Dragons boxed set was on its 4th printing. I don't believe that the contents of the books were significantly different, although the errata sheet that came with the 2nd and 3rd printings is no longer included; it's possible that this printing incorporated those corrections into the text, though I don't have a copy to check.

The main difference is the box, which no longer has a woodgrain pattern with the art pasted to the front. It's is now plain white, with the art printed directly onto the box. The main image, showing a warrior on a rearing horse, has been replaced by a wizard blasting what are probably orcs.

The same mounted warrior has also been replaced on the cover of Vol. 1: Men & Magic, as shown below:

The covers of volumes 2 and 3 have been left untouched. I'm not sure why the mounted warrior was singled out for exclusion, but it could be because it's a very obvious swipe of some Marvel art. Other art swipes still remain, but it's one thing to have these swipes hidden away inside the booklets, and another to have one plastered on the front of your most high-profile product. This is all conjecture, of course, but if I had to hazard a guess this would be it.

Recaps & Roundups part 18: The Strategic Review #4

Issue #4 of The Strategic Review was cover-dated Winter 1975. It's noted in the TSR News article that this issue was late, as is Supplement II: Blackmoor and a number of other design projects. In order to bring some organisation to the company, a few hires have been made: Tim Kask as periodicals editor, Terry Kuntz as service manager, and Dave Arneson as part of the regular design staff. Arneson only lasted about a year with TSR. Kask lasted until 1980, editing their various magazines. As for Terry Kuntz, it's not as easy to find out how long he stayed, so it's going to remain a mystery to me unless someone pipes up in the comments.

It's also noted that Origins I has happened before this issue came out (meaning that an early version of Tomb of Horrors has debuted, as shown in my last post), and that TSR is considering a D&D supplement authored by "Dungeons & Dragons Enthusiasts Everywhere", which I don't think ever eventuated.

Also: THE DRAGON IS COMING.

As for non-D&D articles, there's one listing new troop types for Panzer Warfare, and another with some suggested rules changes for Tractics,

The D&D related-articles, and their relevance to my campaign, are very briefly covered

A Few More Words on Medieval Polearms (by Gary Gygax, who else): The following polearms are introduced:

• Couteaux de Breches (treated as a Glaive)
• Scorpion (treated as a Bill Guisarme)
• Bohemian Ear-Spoon (treated as a Partisan)
• Korseke (treated as a Spetum)
• Chauves Souris (treated as a Ranseur)
• Bec-de-Corbin (treated as a Lucern Hammer with respect to its effect on plate mail; disregarded as an unlikely weapon, except when knights fight afoot on the field of honour)
• Military Fork (discussed, but not equated with any other pole arm)
• Holy Water Sprinklers (treated as Morning Stars, although longer Japanese forms are mentioned)

Chainmail Weapon Additions: The following weapons are introduced to Chainmail:

• Jo Stick
• Bo Stick
• Quarterstaff

I'll throw them into the mix around this time, perhaps due to some growing foreign influence, or the impending growth in influence of Oerth's various orders of monks.

Illusionists (by Peter Aronson): The Illusionist class is added to D&D. It comes with a number of brand new spells:

Level 1

• Wall of Fog
• Change Self
• Gaze Reflection
• Hypnotism

Level 2

• Improved Phantasmal Forces
• Fog
• Blindness
• Misdetection
• Hypnotic Pattern
• Deafness

Level 3

• Fear
• Spectral Forces
• Paralyzation
• Nondetection

Level 4

• Improved Invisibility
• Shadow Monsters
• Shadow Magic
• Minor Creation
• Emotions
• 1st Level Magic-User Spells

Level 5

• Summon Shadow
• Major Creation
• Chaos
• 2nd Level Magic-User Spells
• Demi-Shadow Monsters
• Demi-Shadow Magic
• Create Spectres

I'll probably introduce this class via some NPCs before making it available as a PC class.

Tsolyani Names Without Tears (by M.A.R. Barker): This is a guide to the naming conventions in Barker's Tekumel, the setting for the Empire of the Petal Throne RPG. Articles about this game are all over the early TSR magazines, and I'm probably going to include it as a world that the PCs can travel to.

Creature Feature: The Clay Golem is introduced.

Mighty Magic Miscellany: This introduces a new type of magic item, cribbed from Jack Vance: Ioun Stones. The following colours are used: incandescent blue; scarlet and blue; deep red; pink; pink and green; pale green; pale lavender; pearly white; clear

Gallery of Gunfighters: Doc Holliday is detailed. The Old West will be another possible destination.

Recaps & Roundups part 17: Tomb of Horrors tournament edition

Cover by Tracy Lesch

The first Origins Game Fair was held from the 25th to the 27th of July 1975, at John Hopkins University in Baltimore, Maryland. The fair was to play host to a large D&D tournament, and inspired by Alan Lucien's Tomb of Ra-Hotep, Gary Gygax set about designing a killer dungeon for the event.  The result was the Tomb of Horrors.  Over the course of three days, eight teams of fifteen adventurers went into its depths, and died to its traps. Word spread, and the later groups were better prepared for the dangers of the tomb, but it's deadliness still became legendary. That legend only grew when it became one of the very first official AD&D adventure modules.  Today I'm not looking at the module version, but rather the reprint of the tournament module that came with the Arts & Arcana hardcover.

For the very few (perhaps none) among you who haven't read or played through the Tomb of Horrors, the set-up is this: the lich Acererak has holed up in his trap-filled tomb with all of his treasure, and the PCs want to get in there and take that treasure. There's really not much more to it than that (and what else do you really need?), but the inventiveness and the vindictive nature of some of the traps elevate Tomb of Horrors above other modules of its kind. This one is legendary for a reason, even if you probably never want to run your characters through it.

(As an aside, one of my friends took or group through this module when I was in my early teens, perhaps 12 or 13. We made it through, but upon reading the module later I learned that he had been very lenient with us. We used a wish from a freed efreet to bypass a lot of the tomb, as I recall. I also remember getting blasted by lightning for tap-dancing on an altar, and losing a finger in the devil mouth, but the less said about those events the better.)

I'll try to avoid representing too much of what's in this reprint, but I will post up the map:

The original Tomb of Horrors map

It's a little faded, but for the most part this is a match for the tomb as published. There are some small differences, and at least one room in the published version that's not in the original, but it's very pleasing to note that the two are mostly identical.  I can't vouch for how closely the room descriptions match up, but my read-through of the tournament module all seemed very familiar.  If there are differences, they're in the minor details rather than the major ones.  I might do a close comparison when I get to covering the published module.

After laying out the basic premise, the module goes on to present some possible locations for the module. This is curious, because it can't have been of any relevance to players or DMs at the convention. Regardless of the reason, I appreciate the inclusion. The suggested locations are:

• The highest hill in the Egg of Coot.
• An island lying 100 miles east of Blackmoor.
• In the great desert west of the Wild Coast.
• On the border between the Paynim Kingdom and Perrunland.
• At the eastern edge of the Duchy of Geoff.
• In a swamp somewhere in the Wild Coast.

The published module has a different set of suggestions, and I believe that it eventually gets an official location in the Vast Swamp. I'm open to having the tomb's location move around, magically shifting from place to place.

As for Acererak, he's present in the adventure but I don't believe he is ever named. I'm pretty sure that the term "demi-lich" isn't used either, but he appears here as in the published module, as a floating skull that can drain souls.

Of interest are two phrases that appear during the topic of ways to destroy the lich. It mentions that "the highest Divine destroys it by touch" and that "a Mystic can destroy by mind battle". According to this reprint's introduction, both of these were classes planned for Supplement III: Eldritch Wizardry.  The Mystic was eventually used as fodder for the psionics system, so I'll happily use that title to describe early psionic characters. As for the "Divine", nothing more is said. I'm tempted just to leave it as read, meaning that a divine being can kill the demi-lich with a touch. It's unlikely to come up in play, but you never know.

After the adventure, there's a list of pre-generated PCs for the tournament: two magic-users, two clerics, one paladin, an elven f/m-u, a dwarf fighter, five human fighters, a human thief, a hobbit thief, and a half-elf f/m-u/t.  None of them are named. I'll probably just include them as adventurers who recently entered the tomb and never came back out.

Finally, the adventure includes 24 illustrations to be shown to the players as they explore the tomb. These aren't of the same quality as those in the published module, but by the standards of TSR art in 1975 they're quite good. Here's an example:

A wall carving in the Tomb of Horrors

With two versions of the Tomb now out there, I need to decide which will be included in my campaign. What I'll probably end up doing is using both: initially the tomb will be as described in the tournament module, but eventually it will get upgraded to the published version. It's fine, even Acererak has to do some renovations now and then.